Science

Common mistakes in speed and acceleration

6 mistakes learners make with speed and acceleration, each one named and explained.

All common mistakes

Speed is distance for each second; acceleration is change in speed for each second.

A number from the question copied out

What it looks like

The answer given is one of the values printed in the question, unchanged.

Why it happens

When a calculation will not come, the numbers on the page are the only thing to hold on to.

A worked example

Question. 240 m in 12 s

A common answer. 12 m/s

The answer. 20 m/s

Why. The 12 was the time, so it cannot also be the speed.

Put the two side by side

12 is a time in seconds.
20 is a speed in metres per second.

Check the unit of your answer against the unit of the number you wrote down.

Multiplying where you should divide

What it looks like

Every quantity in the question gets multiplied together, so 150 m in 10 s becomes 1500 m/s.

Why it happens

Multiplying is the operation you reach for first, and the numbers do combine, just not that way.

A worked example

Question. A car goes 150 m in 10 s

A common answer. 150 x 10 = 1500 m/s

The answer. 150 / 10 = 15 m/s

Why. Ten seconds of travel cannot be faster than one second of travel.

Put the two side by side

Multiplying makes the answer bigger.
Sharing 150 m across 10 s makes it smaller.

Decide first whether the answer should be bigger or smaller than what you started with.

The answer out by a factor of ten

What it looks like

The division is set up correctly and the decimal point lands in the wrong place, so 150 divided by 10 comes out as 1.5.

Why it happens

Dividing by ten shifts the digits, and shifting them the wrong way looks identical on paper.

A worked example

Question. 150 m in 10 s

A common answer. 1.5 m/s

The answer. 15 m/s

Why. Dividing by 10 makes 150 into 15, not into 1.5.

Put the two side by side

1.5 m/s is slower than walking pace.
15 m/s is about 34 miles per hour.

Estimate the answer roughly before dividing. Being out by ten is always visible against an estimate.

The division done upside down

What it looks like

You divide the smaller number by the larger one, so a speed of 15 m/s comes out as 0.067.

Why it happens

A triangle mnemonic tells you three letters but not which one sits on top, and dividing the small number by the big one feels safer.

A worked example

Question. A car goes 150 m in 10 s

A common answer. 10 / 150 = 0.067 m/s

The answer. 150 / 10 = 15 m/s

Why. Speed is metres for each second, so the metres go on top.

Put the two side by side

0.067 m/s is slower than walking.
15 m/s is about 34 miles per hour.

Ask what the unit says. Metres per second means metres divided by seconds, in that order.

The starting speed left out

What it looks like

Acceleration from 4 m/s to 16 m/s is worked out using 16 alone.

Why it happens

The final speed is the one the question ends on, so it feels like the number to use.

A worked example

Question. 4 m/s to 16 m/s in 6 s

A common answer. 16 / 6 = 2.7 m/s^2

The answer. (16 - 4) / 6 = 2 m/s^2

Why. Acceleration is the change in speed, so the starting speed has to be taken off.

Put the two side by side

Starting from rest: the final speed is the change.
Starting from 4 m/s: only 12 m/s of it is new.

Acceleration always uses a difference. From rest is the special case where it looks like it does not.

The time never used at all

What it looks like

A car travelling 150 m in 10 s is given a speed of 150 m/s, the distance copied out.

Why it happens

The distance is the number the question is about, so it feels like the answer.

A worked example

Question. 150 m in 10 s

A common answer. 150 m/s

The answer. 15 m/s

Why. 150 m/s would be faster than a passenger jet.

Put the two side by side

150 is how far it went.
15 is how far it went each second.

A speed always has two units in it. If your answer used only one number, it is not a speed.

WAJD spots these patterns in your child's answers and names the one behind their wrong answers, instead of just marking them wrong.

More science topics