Science

Common mistakes in cells

6 mistakes learners make with cells, each one named and explained.

All common mistakes

Each part of a cell has one job, and the job explains the shape.

A bacterium given a nucleus

What it looks like

The genetic material of a bacterial cell is placed inside a true nucleus.

Why it happens

Every cell diagram you have ever drawn had a nucleus in the middle of it.

A worked example

Question. Where is the DNA in a bacterial cell

A common answer. in the nucleus

The answer. in a single loop, free in the cytoplasm

Why. Prokaryote means before the nucleus, which is exactly what the word is telling you.

Put the two side by side

Eukaryotes keep DNA inside a nucleus.
Prokaryotes have no nucleus at all.

The name of the group is the answer. Pro-karyote: no proper nucleus.

Magnification worked out by adding or by dividing the wrong way

What it looks like

An image 20 mm long of a cell 0.1 mm long is given a magnification of 2, or of 20.1.

Why it happens

Three quantities share one equation, and which one goes on top is remembered as a shape rather than as a meaning.

A worked example

Question. An image is 20 mm long. The real cell is 0.1 mm long. What is the magnification?

A common answer. x 2

The answer. x 200

Why. Magnification = image size divided by real size = 20 / 0.1 = 200.

Put the two side by side

Magnification says how many times bigger the image is than the real thing.
So image size divided by real size, and the answer is always more than 1.

Check both lengths are in the same unit first, then ask how many times bigger.

Membrane-bound organelles given to a bacterium

What it looks like

A bacterium is described as keeping its DNA in the mitochondria or a chloroplast.

Why it happens

Those are the organelles most recently learned, so they are the ones that come to mind.

A worked example

Question. Where is bacterial DNA

A common answer. inside the mitochondria

The answer. free in the cytoplasm

Why. Bacteria have none of the membrane-bound organelles.

Put the two side by side

Animal and plant cells have organelles inside membranes.
Bacteria have ribosomes and a cell wall, and little else.

If it has a membrane around it and is inside a cell, a bacterium does not have it.

Plant and animal cell parts mixed up

What it looks like

A part both cells share, such as the cell membrane or a mitochondrion, is given as plant only.

Why it happens

The plant cell diagram is drawn with more labels, so every label on it looks like a plant feature.

A worked example

Question. Which part is in a plant cell but not an animal cell

A common answer. the cell membrane

The answer. the cell wall

Why. Animal cells have membranes too. Only the wall, the chloroplasts and the large vacuole are extra.

Put the two side by side

Both cells: membrane, cytoplasm, nucleus, mitochondria, ribosomes.
Plant only: cell wall, chloroplasts, large permanent vacuole.

Learn the short list of three extras rather than the long list of everything.

The cell wall thought to control what enters the cell

What it looks like

A plant cell's wall is said to decide which substances get in and out.

Why it happens

The wall is the outermost layer, and the outside of anything is pictured as its gate.

A worked example

Question. Which part of a plant cell controls what enters and leaves it?

A common answer. the cell wall

The answer. the cell membrane, just inside the wall

Why. The wall is strong and lets most substances through. The membrane is the part that chooses.

Put the two side by side

Cell wall: supports the cell and keeps its shape.
Cell membrane: controls what passes in and out.

Every cell has a membrane. A wall is extra, for strength, and does no choosing.

The right part, the wrong job

What it looks like

A cell part is named correctly but paired with another part's job, such as the nucleus controlling what enters the cell.

Why it happens

The parts are learned as a labelled diagram, and a diagram shows where things are, not what they do.

A worked example

Question. Which part controls what enters and leaves the cell

A common answer. the nucleus

The answer. the cell membrane

Why. The membrane is the only part that surrounds the cell, so it is the only one that can control the boundary.

Put the two side by side

The nucleus holds the instructions.
The membrane is the border.

Learn each part by the one job only it can do, and its position stops being the thing you remember.

WAJD spots these patterns in your child's answers and names the one behind their wrong answers, instead of just marking them wrong.

More science topics