Science

Common mistakes in rocks and the rock cycle

6 mistakes learners make with rocks and the rock cycle, each one named and explained.

All common mistakes

How a rock formed is what names it, not what it looks like.

A property offered as a rock type

What it looks like

Magnetic or soluble is chosen as one of the three rock types.

Why it happens

It is a real word about rocks, and the three real types are not securely known.

A worked example

Question. The three rock types

A common answer. magnetic

The answer. igneous, sedimentary, metamorphic

Why. Magnetic describes what a rock does, not how it formed.

Put the two side by side

There are exactly three types, all named by formation.
Any other adjective is describing a property.

Learn the three as a closed list. Anything outside it is not an option.

A rock type matched to the wrong formation

What it looks like

Igneous or metamorphic is given for rock formed from layers of sediment.

Why it happens

Three names, three processes, and nothing about the names says which is which.

A worked example

Question. Rock formed from layers of sediment squashed over time

A common answer. igneous

The answer. sedimentary

Why. Sedimentary is named directly after sediment.

Put the two side by side

Igneous: cooled from molten rock, and ignis means fire.
Sedimentary: settled sediment. Metamorphic: changed by heat and pressure.

Each name describes its own process once you hear the root inside it.

Fast cooling expected to make large crystals

What it looks like

You say lava that cools quickly forms large crystals.

Why it happens

Speed is pictured as producing more, so quick cooling seems to make more crystal.

A worked example

Question. Magma cools slowly deep underground. What size are the crystals?

A common answer. Small

The answer. Large

Why. Slow cooling gives the crystals time to grow.

Put the two side by side

Slow cooling underground: large crystals, as in granite.
Fast cooling at the surface: small crystals, as in basalt.

The more time magma has to cool, the bigger its crystals grow.

Fossils expected in any type of rock

What it looks like

You say fossils are often found in igneous rock such as granite.

Why it happens

Fossils are found in rock, and any rock seems as likely as another.

A worked example

Question. Which type of rock usually contains fossils?

A common answer. Igneous

The answer. Sedimentary

Why. Remains are buried in layers of sediment; molten rock would destroy them.

Put the two side by side

Sedimentary: laid down in layers, can trap and keep remains.
Igneous: formed from molten rock, which would destroy remains.

Fossils need gentle burial, not melting.

Metamorphic rock thought to form by melting

What it looks like

You say metamorphic rock forms when rock melts and cools again.

Why it happens

Heat is involved, and heated rock is pictured melting.

A worked example

Question. How is metamorphic rock formed?

A common answer. Rock melts and then cools

The answer. Heat and pressure change rock without melting it

Why. If it melted and cooled, it would be igneous.

Put the two side by side

Melted and cooled: igneous.
Changed by heat and pressure while still solid: metamorphic.

Did it melt? If yes, igneous. If no, metamorphic.

The rock cycle run backwards

What it looks like

Sedimentary rock is said to form before the sediment it is made of.

Why it happens

Rock is the more substantial thing, so it feels like the starting point.

A worked example

Question. Which forms first, sediment or sedimentary rock

A common answer. sedimentary rock

The answer. sediment, which is then compacted and cemented into rock

Why. You cannot compact something that does not exist yet.

Put the two side by side

Weathering makes sediment.
Burial and pressure turn sediment into rock.

Every step of the rock cycle has an input. Name the input and the order fixes itself.

WAJD spots these patterns in your child's answers and names the one behind their wrong answers, instead of just marking them wrong.

More science topics