Science

Common mistakes in homeostasis

4 mistakes learners make with homeostasis, each one named and explained.

All common mistakes

Every control in the body is a loop: something detects the change, something coordinates, and something acts.

A response named without saying what it achieves

What it looks like

You answer that you shiver and your hairs stand up, and stop there.

Why it happens

The question looks like it is asking what happens, and those are the things that happen.

A worked example

Question. Why does shivering help when you are cold?

A common answer. it is just what the body does when it is cold

The answer. muscles contracting rapidly release heat from respiration

Why. A response only earns the mark when you say what it does to the thing being controlled.

Put the two side by side

Naming the response answers what.
Saying what it achieves answers why.

Finish every response with the words so that, then say what it changes.

Body temperature kept steady for no stated reason

What it looks like

You say a high temperature is dangerous without mentioning what it does to enzymes.

Why it happens

That a fever is bad is obvious from experience, so the reason never gets asked for.

A worked example

Question. Why is a body temperature of 40 degrees C dangerous?

A common answer. because it feels unpleasant and makes you weak

The answer. because enzymes begin to denature, so reactions in cells slow or stop

Why. The whole point of holding 37 degrees C is that it is the temperature the body's enzymes work best at.

Put the two side by side

A high temperature is uncomfortable.
A high temperature denatures enzymes.

Every temperature answer in biology ends at enzymes. Get there.

The brain left out of the control loop

What it looks like

You explain shivering as the body getting cold and shivering, with nothing in between.

Why it happens

The change and the response are both things you can feel, and the detecting and coordinating happen out of sight.

A worked example

Question. You get cold and begin to shiver. What happened in between?

A common answer. nothing, the body just shivers when it is cold

The answer. receptors detected the drop and the brain coordinated the response

Why. Every control in the body is detect, coordinate, respond, and leaving out the middle step loses the marks.

Put the two side by side

Cold, then shivering, is a description.
Receptor, brain, effector is an explanation.

Name all three stages every time, even when the middle one is invisible.

The jobs of the kidney and the bladder swapped

What it looks like

You write that the bladder filters the blood, or that the kidney stores urine.

Why it happens

Both are to do with urine and they are learned as a pair, so the two names swap easily.

A worked example

Question. Which organ filters the blood?

A common answer. the bladder

The answer. the kidney

Why. The kidney filters and adjusts; the bladder only stores what the kidney has already made.

Put the two side by side

The kidney filters the blood and makes urine.
The bladder stores it until you go.

Filtering happens where the blood goes. Blood does not flow into the bladder.

WAJD spots these patterns in your child's answers and names the one behind their wrong answers, instead of just marking them wrong.

More science topics