Science

Common mistakes in energy stores and transfers

8 mistakes learners make with energy stores and transfers, each one named and explained.

All common mistakes

Energy is never made or destroyed. It moves between stores, and some of it always spreads out.

A physics term swapped for a similar one

What it looks like

Current is described where voltage belongs, or mass where weight belongs.

Why it happens

Physics words come in close pairs that describe different parts of the same picture, and the nearer word arrives first.

A worked example

Question. What does an ammeter measure?

A common answer. The push of the battery

The answer. The current flowing through the circuit

Why. An ammeter counts the flow of charge, which is current. The push is the potential difference, and a voltmeter measures that.

Put the two side by side

Voltage is the push across a component.
Current is the flow through it.

Tie each word to its picture: push across, flow through.

Conservation of energy read as perfect efficiency

What it looks like

A device is given 100 per cent efficiency because energy is conserved.

Why it happens

If no energy is lost, it sounds as though nothing can be wasted.

A worked example

Question. A lamp giving 20 J of light from 100 J

A common answer. 100 per cent efficient

The answer. 20 per cent efficient

Why. All 100 J is still there, but 80 J of it is heat nobody wanted.

Put the two side by side

Conserved: the total is unchanged.
Efficient: how much of the total ended up where you wanted it.

Energy is always conserved and almost nothing is ever fully efficient. Both at once.

Energy described as being made

What it looks like

Mitochondria or a power station is said to make or produce energy.

Why it happens

Everyday language says exactly this, including on electricity bills.

A worked example

Question. What mitochondria do

A common answer. they make energy

The answer. they release energy from glucose by respiration

Why. The energy was already in the glucose; respiration transfers it into a usable form.

Put the two side by side

Made: something that did not exist now does.
Released or transferred: it was already there, in another store.

Never write makes energy in science. Write releases, transfers or stores.

Energy thought to be used up

What it looks like

Conservation of energy is stated as energy being used up or running out.

Why it happens

Batteries go flat and fuel runs out, which is exactly what being used up looks like.

A worked example

Question. What conservation of energy says

A common answer. energy gets used up

The answer. energy is never created or destroyed, only transferred

Why. The energy in a flat battery has moved into heat and light, not vanished.

Put the two side by side

Useful energy runs out.
Total energy stays exactly the same, spread more thinly.

Nothing is used up. It is dissipated, which means spread out and harder to use.

One quantity left out of the formula

What it looks like

Gravitational potential energy is worked out as mass times height, with g never used.

Why it happens

Three numbers in a row is a lot to hold, and the one that is a constant looks optional.

A worked example

Question. 2 kg lifted 3 m, g = 9.8

A common answer. 2 x 3 = 6 J

The answer. 2 x 9.8 x 3 = 58.8 J

Why. Every letter in the formula is there because the answer depends on it.

Put the two side by side

mass x height uses two of the three.
mass x g x height uses all three.

Write the formula out first, then tick each letter off as you substitute it.

The half in the kinetic energy formula dropped

What it looks like

Kinetic energy comes out at exactly double, because the 0.5 was never applied.

Why it happens

The half looks like decoration next to the mass and the speed squared.

A worked example

Question. 1000 kg at 20 m/s

A common answer. 1000 x 400 = 400000 J

The answer. 0.5 x 1000 x 400 = 200000 J

Why. The half is part of the formula, not a rounding.

Put the two side by side

400000 J is the answer without the half.
200000 J is the answer with it.

If your answer is exactly double the expected size, look for a missing half.

The wasted energy given as the efficiency

What it looks like

A lamp giving 20 J of light from 100 J is called 80 per cent efficient.

Why it happens

Eighty is the larger number and larger sounds better for an efficiency.

A worked example

Question. 100 J in, 20 J of useful light out

A common answer. 80 per cent

The answer. 20 per cent

Why. Efficiency counts the useful output, and the useful output is the light.

Put the two side by side

20 J is the useful output.
80 J is wasted as heat.

Efficiency is useful over total. Find the useful output before you divide anything.

The wrong energy store named

What it looks like

A store is chosen that does not change in the situation described, such as chemical for a lifted book.

Why it happens

Several stores change a little in any real situation, so the one the question is about is not obvious.

A worked example

Question. Lifting a book onto a shelf

A common answer. the chemical store increases

The answer. the gravitational potential store increases

Why. Chemical energy in your muscles falls; the book gains gravitational potential energy.

Put the two side by side

Ask what changed about the object.
Higher up: gravitational. Moving: kinetic. Hotter: thermal. Stretched: elastic.

Name the object first, then ask what is different about it now.

WAJD spots these patterns in your child's answers and names the one behind their wrong answers, instead of just marking them wrong.

More science topics