Maths

Common mistakes in vector arithmetic

6 mistakes learners make with vector arithmetic, each one named and explained.

All common mistakes

Add or subtract the components separately, and keep the signs.

A column vector read as a fraction

What it looks like

The vector with 6 on top and 3 underneath is simplified to 2, or treated as 6 divided by 3.

Why it happens

Two numbers stacked one above the other look exactly like a fraction without its line.

A worked example

Question. What does the column vector with 6 on top and 3 underneath mean?

A common answer. 6 divided by 3, which is 2

The answer. 6 across and 3 up

Why. The top number is the move across and the bottom number is the move up. Nothing is divided.

Put the two side by side

A fraction: one number divided by another.
A column vector: two separate moves, across then up.

Read a column vector as an instruction: top number across, bottom number up.

A negative vector thought to be shorter

What it looks like

-a is described as a smaller version of a, rather than the same length in the opposite direction.

Why it happens

With ordinary numbers, a minus sign makes a number less, so it is expected to shrink the arrow.

A worked example

Question. a is an arrow 5 units long pointing east. Describe -a.

A common answer. A shorter arrow pointing east

The answer. An arrow 5 units long pointing west

Why. Multiplying by -1 keeps the length and reverses the direction.

Put the two side by side

1/2 a: same direction, half the length.
-a: same length, opposite direction.

A number in front of a vector changes its length. A minus sign turns it round.

One component added, the other subtracted

What it looks like

The two components are treated differently, usually where one of them is negative.

Why it happens

A negative component makes adding look like subtracting, so the operation flips halfway.

A worked example

Question. (3, -2) + (1, 4)

A common answer. (4, -6)

The answer. (4, 2)

Why. Minus 2 plus 4 is 2, because adding to a negative number moves it upwards.

Put the two side by side

3 + 1 = 4, handled correctly.
-2 + 4 = 2, not -6.

Do each component as its own small sum, written out. Negative numbers cause this every time.

The components multiplied

What it looks like

Corresponding components are multiplied together rather than added.

Why it happens

Two lists of numbers side by side invites combining them however seems natural.

A worked example

Question. (3, -2) + (1, 4)

A common answer. (3, -8)

The answer. (4, 2)

Why. Adding vectors means adding each pair of components.

Put the two side by side

Multiplying: (3, -8).
Adding: (4, 2).

The operation in the question applies to each component separately, unchanged.

The multiplier added to each component

What it looks like

2p is worked out by adding 2 to each component.

Why it happens

Both operations use the same two symbols side by side and neither is written out in words.

A worked example

Question. p = (5, -3), find 2p

A common answer. (7, -1)

The answer. (10, -6)

Why. 2p means two of the vector p, which is p added to itself.

Put the two side by side

Adding 2: (7, -1).
Doubling: (10, -6).

Read 2p as two lots of p. Two lots is always a multiplication.

a - b worked out as b - a

What it looks like

With a = (5, 2) and b = (1, 4), a - b is given as (-4, 2).

Why it happens

Taking the smaller from the larger in each part feels safer than ending with a negative component.

A worked example

Question. a = (5, 2) and b = (1, 4). Work out a - b.

A common answer. (4, 2)

The answer. (4, -2)

Why. Subtract each part in order: 5 - 1 = 4 and 2 - 4 = -2.

Put the two side by side

a - b = (4, -2).
b - a = (-4, 2), the same arrow pointing the other way.

Keep the order the question gives in every component, even when it goes negative.

WAJD spots these patterns in your child's answers and names the one behind their wrong answers, instead of just marking them wrong.

More maths topics