Maths

Common mistakes in the discriminant

5 mistakes learners make with the discriminant, each one named and explained.

All common mistakes

b squared minus 4ac decides how many real roots there are, and equal roots means it is zero.

A surd left unsimplified

What it looks like

The answer is correct in value but written as 2 root 8 rather than in its simplest form.

Why it happens

The value is right, so there is nothing to prompt a further step.

A worked example

Question. k^2 = 64

A common answer. k = plus or minus 2 root 8

The answer. k = plus or minus 8

Why. 2 root 8 is 2 times 2 root 2, which is 4 root 2, and in this case the answer was a whole number anyway.

Put the two side by side

2 root 8: a correct value, badly written.
8: the same value, simplified.

Always take the largest square factor out of a surd, and check whether it was a whole number all along.

The coefficient not halved when completing the square

What it looks like

x^2 + 6x becomes (x + 6)^2 rather than (x + 3)^2.

Why it happens

The 6 is the number in the expression and using it directly needs no extra thought.

A worked example

Question. x^2 + 6x + 11

A common answer. (x + 6)^2 - 25

The answer. (x + 3)^2 + 2

Why. Expanding (x + 3)^2 gives x^2 + 6x + 9, which is where the 6x comes from.

Put the two side by side

(x + 6)^2 expands to x^2 + 12x + 36.
(x + 3)^2 expands to x^2 + 6x + 9.

Halve the x coefficient. Expanding your bracket back is the check that never fails.

The constant adjustment given the wrong sign

What it looks like

The completed square ends with the wrong sign on the final number.

Why it happens

There are two subtractions in a row and one of them is easy to invert.

A worked example

Question. x^2 + 6x + 11

A common answer. (x + 3)^2 - 2

The answer. (x + 3)^2 + 2

Why. (x + 3)^2 is x^2 + 6x + 9, and 11 is 2 more than 9, so 2 is added.

Put the two side by side

(x + 3)^2 - 2 expands to x^2 + 6x + 7.
(x + 3)^2 + 2 expands to x^2 + 6x + 11.

Expand your answer back. It has to reproduce the original constant exactly.

The sign of 4ac handled wrongly

What it looks like

4ac is added instead of subtracted, or its sign is lost when a or c is negative.

Why it happens

Two minus signs in one expression, and one of them belongs to a coefficient.

A worked example

Question. x^2 + 4x + 5 = 0

A common answer. 16 + 20 = 36

The answer. 16 - 20 = -4

Why. The formula subtracts 4ac, and here 4ac is positive 20.

Put the two side by side

16 + 20 = 36, which would mean two real roots.
16 - 20 = -4, which means none.

Work out 4ac as its own number first, sign included, then subtract it.

b used without squaring it

What it looks like

The discriminant is worked out as b minus 4ac, with the square never applied.

Why it happens

The formula is remembered as b something minus 4ac, and the square is the small part.

A worked example

Question. x^2 + 4x + 5 = 0

A common answer. 4 - 20 = -16

The answer. 16 - 20 = -4

Why. The discriminant is b squared minus 4ac, so the 4 is squared first.

Put the two side by side

b - 4ac: not a discriminant.
b^2 - 4ac: the discriminant.

Work out b squared as its own number and write it down before subtracting anything.

WAJD spots these patterns in your child's answers and names the one behind their wrong answers, instead of just marking them wrong.

More maths topics