Maths

Common mistakes in integration

10 mistakes learners make with integration, each one named and explained.

All common mistakes

Raise the power by one, then divide by the new power.

A constant term not integrated

What it looks like

The constant 3 stays as 3 instead of becoming 3x.

Why it happens

Constants vanish when differentiating, so it is easy to treat them as inert.

A worked example

Question. integrate 3

A common answer. 3

The answer. 3x + c

Why. Integrating is the reverse, so a constant becomes a term in x.

Put the two side by side

Differentiating 3x gives 3.
So integrating 3 gives 3x.

Every term gains a power when integrated, including the ones that had none.

Divided by the original power rather than the new one

What it looks like

6x^2 integrates to 3x^3, dividing by 2 instead of 3.

Why it happens

The power in the question is the one in front of you when you divide.

A worked example

Question. 6x^2

A common answer. 3x^3 + c

The answer. 2x^3 + c

Why. You divide by the power you have just created, not the one you started with.

Put the two side by side

Divide by 2: 3x^3, which differentiates to 9x^2.
Divide by 3: 2x^3, which differentiates to 6x^2.

Raise the power first and write it down. Then divide by the number you just wrote.

Multiplied by the inner coefficient instead of divided

What it looks like

sin(3x) integrates to -3cos(3x), when it should be divided by 3.

Why it happens

The chain rule multiplies when differentiating, and integrating feels like the same operation.

A worked example

Question. integrate sin(3x)

A common answer. -3cos(3x) + c

The answer. -(1/3)cos(3x) + c

Why. Differentiating -(1/3)cos(3x) gives sin(3x), which is the check.

Put the two side by side

Differentiating multiplies by the inner coefficient.
Integrating divides by it.

Everything reverses when you integrate, including the direction of that step.

Only the upper limit substituted

What it looks like

The integral is evaluated at the top limit and the bottom one is never taken off.

Why it happens

The upper limit is substituted first, and its value looks like an answer.

A worked example

Question. integral of 3x^2 + 2 from 1 to 3

A common answer. 27 + 6 = 33

The answer. 33 - 3 = 30

Why. A definite integral is the value at the top minus the value at the bottom.

Put the two side by side

Top only: 33.
Top minus bottom: 30.

Write the square brackets with both limits before substituting. The subtraction is then already on the page.

The function not changed

What it looks like

sin integrates to sin, with only the coefficient adjusted.

Why it happens

The coefficient work is where the attention goes, and the function itself gets copied across.

A worked example

Question. integrate sin(3x)

A common answer. -(1/3)sin(3x) + c

The answer. -(1/3)cos(3x) + c

Why. Integrating sin gives a cosine, because differentiating cosine is what produces a sine.

Put the two side by side

Same function: nothing was integrated.
sin becomes cos: the function changed, as it must.

Sin and cos always swap. If yours did not, only the coefficient was handled.

The inner coefficient not accounted for at all

What it looks like

1/(2x - 5) integrates to ln|2x - 5| with no factor of a half.

Why it happens

The logarithm is the part that has to be recalled, and it feels like the whole answer.

A worked example

Question. integrate 1/(2x - 5)

A common answer. ln|2x - 5| + c

The answer. (1/2)ln|2x - 5| + c

Why. Differentiating ln|2x - 5| gives 2/(2x - 5), which is twice too big.

Put the two side by side

No factor: differentiates to twice the original.
With the half: differentiates back exactly.

Differentiate your answer. Any spare factor tells you what you missed.

The limits subtracted the wrong way

What it looks like

The lower limit's value is subtracted from nothing, or the two are reversed, giving a negative.

Why it happens

Two numbers and a subtraction, and the order is decided by the notation rather than by meaning.

A worked example

Question. integral from 1 to 3

A common answer. value at 1 minus value at 3, giving -30

The answer. 30

Why. The upper limit always comes first in the subtraction.

Put the two side by side

Reversed: -30.
In order: 30.

An area under a positive curve cannot be negative. That is the check.

The power raised without dividing

What it looks like

6x^2 integrates to 6x^3, with no division by the new power.

Why it happens

Raising the power is the visible reversal of differentiating, and the division is the quiet half.

A worked example

Question. 6x^2

A common answer. 6x^3 + c

The answer. 2x^3 + c

Why. The new power is 3, so the coefficient is divided by 3.

Put the two side by side

Raise only: 6x^3.
Raise and divide: 2x^3.

Differentiate your answer back. It has to return exactly what you started with.

The power rule used on a reciprocal

What it looks like

1/(2x - 5) is integrated by raising the power, giving a squared bracket.

Why it happens

The power rule is the default and 1 over something is a power of minus one.

A worked example

Question. integrate 1/(2x - 5)

A common answer. (1/2)(2x - 5)^2 + c

The answer. (1/2)ln|2x - 5| + c

Why. Raising a power of -1 by one gives a power of 0, which is why the rule breaks down here.

Put the two side by side

The power rule works for every power except -1.
For -1 the answer is a logarithm.

Whenever the power is exactly -1, stop and reach for ln instead.

The sign lost integrating a trigonometric function

What it looks like

sin integrates to positive cos rather than negative cos.

Why it happens

Four sign rules across sin and cos, differentiating and integrating, and only one of them is wrong.

A worked example

Question. integrate sin(3x)

A common answer. (1/3)cos(3x) + c

The answer. -(1/3)cos(3x) + c

Why. Differentiating cos gives minus sin, so integrating sin has to give minus cos.

Put the two side by side

Differentiate: sin goes to cos, cos goes to -sin.
Integrate: sin goes to -cos, cos goes to sin.

Only one of the four carries a minus in each direction. Differentiate your answer to find out which.

WAJD spots these patterns in your child's answers and names the one behind their wrong answers, instead of just marking them wrong.

More maths topics