Maths

Common mistakes in the product rule

6 mistakes learners make with the product rule, each one named and explained.

All common mistakes

First times the derivative of the second, plus second times the derivative of the first.

Only one term of the product rule written

What it looks like

One of the two terms is produced and the other never appears.

Why it happens

The rule is a long expression and stopping halfway still leaves something plausible.

A worked example

Question. x^2 sin(x)

A common answer. x^2 cos(x)

The answer. 2x sin(x) + x^2 cos(x)

Why. Each factor takes a turn at being differentiated, giving two terms.

Put the two side by side

One term: half the answer.
Two terms added: the whole of it.

Write the plus sign and the second term's skeleton before you fill anything in.

The chain rule forgotten inside one part of a product

What it looks like

x(2x + 1)^3 differentiates to (2x + 1)^3 + 3x(2x + 1)^2, with the 2 from the inside missing.

Why it happens

Attention goes to fitting the product rule together, so the chain rule inside one part is skipped.

A worked example

Question. Differentiate x(2x + 1)^3

A common answer. (2x + 1)^3 + 3x(2x + 1)^2

The answer. (2x + 1)^3 + 6x(2x + 1)^2

Why. The derivative of (2x + 1)^3 is 3(2x + 1)^2 x 2 = 6(2x + 1)^2.

Put the two side by side

u = x, so u' = 1.
v = (2x + 1)^3, so v' = 6(2x + 1)^2, chain rule included.

Write u, v, u' and v' out separately before putting them together.

The minus lost when cos is differentiated

What it looks like

x cos x differentiates to cos x + x sin x.

Why it happens

The derivatives of sin and cos are remembered as swapping, and the minus that comes with cos is dropped.

A worked example

Question. Differentiate x cos x

A common answer. cos x + x sin x

The answer. cos x - x sin x

Why. The derivative of cos x is -sin x, so the second term is x times -sin x.

Put the two side by side

d/dx sin x = cos x.
d/dx cos x = -sin x.

Sin to cos keeps the sign. Cos to sin brings a minus.

The product rule terms subtracted

What it looks like

The two terms are joined with a minus sign.

Why it happens

The quotient rule has a minus in it, and the two rules are learned together.

A worked example

Question. x^2 sin(x)

A common answer. 2x sin(x) - x^2 cos(x)

The answer. 2x sin(x) + x^2 cos(x)

Why. The product rule adds its two terms; only the quotient rule subtracts.

Put the two side by side

Product rule: plus.
Quotient rule: minus.

Check which rule you are using before writing the connecting sign.

The product rule used where the parts are added

What it looks like

x^2 + sin x is differentiated with the product rule, giving 2x sin x + x^2 cos x.

Why it happens

Two different functions side by side look like a job for the product rule, whatever joins them.

A worked example

Question. Differentiate x^2 + sin x

A common answer. 2x sin x + x^2 cos x

The answer. 2x + cos x

Why. The terms are added, not multiplied, so each is differentiated on its own.

Put the two side by side

x^2 sin x: a product, so use the product rule.
x^2 + sin x: a sum, so differentiate term by term.

Check the sign between the two parts. Only multiplying calls for the product rule.

The two derivatives simply multiplied together

What it looks like

x^2 sin x differentiates to 2x cos x, both parts differentiated at once.

Why it happens

It is what the product rule would be if differentiation behaved like the operation it is applied to.

A worked example

Question. x^2 sin(x)

A common answer. 2x cos(x)

The answer. 2x sin(x) + x^2 cos(x)

Why. The derivative of a product is not the product of the derivatives.

Put the two side by side

Product of the derivatives: 2x cos x.
Product rule: one differentiated at a time, then added.

Two terms come out of the product rule, always. A single term means it was not used.

WAJD spots these patterns in your child's answers and names the one behind their wrong answers, instead of just marking them wrong.

More maths topics