Maths

Common mistakes in vector arithmetic

5 mistakes learners make with vector arithmetic, each one named and explained.

All common mistakes

Scalars multiply every component, and the components stay separate throughout.

A multiplier applied to only one component

What it looks like

2p doubles the first component and leaves the second as it was.

Why it happens

The multiplier is written once, to the left, so it looks as though it acts once.

A worked example

Question. p = (5, -3), find 2p

A common answer. (10, -3)

The answer. (10, -6)

Why. The multiplier acts on the whole vector, so both parts double.

Put the two side by side

(10, -3): only half the vector was scaled.
(10, -6): both parts scaled.

A scalar multiplies everything inside the bracket, exactly as in algebra.

A scalar multiplier ignored

What it looks like

a + 2b is worked out as a + b, with the 2 never used.

Why it happens

The letters are what the expression is about and the small number in front is easy to read past.

A worked example

Question. a = 3i - 2j, b = i + 4j, find a + 2b

A common answer. 4i + 2j

The answer. 5i + 6j

Why. 2b is 2i + 8j, so both components of b double before adding.

Put the two side by side

a + b: 4i + 2j.
a + 2b: 5i + 6j.

Work out 2b as its own vector on a separate line, then add.

The multiplier applied to the starting position too

What it looks like

Position after 3 seconds is found by multiplying both the start and the velocity by 3.

Why it happens

The 3 is the number the question turns on, so it gets applied to everything in sight.

A worked example

Question. Start at 4i - 3j, velocity 2i + 5j, after 3 seconds

A common answer. 3(4i - 3j) + 3(2i + 5j)

The answer. (4i - 3j) + 3(2i + 5j)

Why. The starting position happens once; only the velocity accumulates with time.

Put the two side by side

The start is where it was, once.
The velocity is added once for every second.

Only the rate gets multiplied by the time. The starting point is added exactly once.

The subtraction done in the wrong order

What it looks like

a minus b is worked out as b minus a, so every sign is reversed.

Why it happens

Subtraction order is invisible in a column of numbers and both orders look equally plausible.

A worked example

Question. a = (2, 5), b = (7, 1), find a - b

A common answer. (5, -4)

The answer. (-5, 4)

Why. The first vector named is the one you start from.

Put the two side by side

a - b: (-5, 4).
b - a: (5, -4).

The two answers are exact opposites. If yours has every sign flipped, the order is reversed.

Vectors subtracted instead of added

What it looks like

The components are subtracted when the question asked for a sum.

Why it happens

Vector questions come in matched pairs of adding and subtracting and the sign is one small symbol.

A worked example

Question. (3, -2) + (1, 4)

A common answer. (2, -6)

The answer. (4, 2)

Why. Adding means both components go up by the second vector.

Put the two side by side

a + b: components added.
a - b: components subtracted.

Read the sign in the question aloud before starting. It is the only thing that differs.

WAJD spots these patterns in your child's answers and names the one behind their wrong answers, instead of just marking them wrong.

More maths topics