Maths

Common mistakes in turning a problem into an equation

4 mistakes learners make with turning a problem into an equation, each one named and explained.

All common mistakes

The equation has to say what the situation says, so name what you do not know, write the sentence in symbols, and check it against the words before solving.

A negative root kept as a length

What it looks like

A quadratic modelling a garden gives two roots and the negative one is offered as the answer.

Why it happens

Both roots solve the equation, and rejecting one feels like throwing away correct work.

A worked example

Question. A garden of length x + 2 and width x has area 35

A common answer. x = -7

The answer. x = 5

Why. A garden cannot have a width of minus seven metres.

Put the two side by side

Both roots solve the equation.
Only one of them describes a real garden.

When a quadratic models something physical, check both roots against the situation before answering.

Only two sides counted

What it looks like

Perimeter is given as length plus width, with the opposite pair never added.

Why it happens

A rectangle is described by two numbers, so it feels as though two lengths is the whole of it.

A worked example

Question. A garden 12 m by 5 m

A common answer. 12 + 5 = 17

The answer. 12 + 5 + 12 + 5 = 34

Why. A rectangle has four sides, and the opposite ones are equal but still there.

Put the two side by side

Two sides: 17 m.
All four sides: 34 m.

Walk round the shape and count what you walk along. You cross four sides, not two.

Perimeter given where area was asked for

What it looks like

The distance round the edge is calculated and offered as the area.

Why it happens

Both are worked out from the same two lengths, and both are called the size of the shape.

A worked example

Question. A rectangle 8 cm by 5 cm

A common answer. 2 x (8 + 5) = 26

The answer. 8 x 5 = 40

Why. Area counts the squares inside; perimeter measures the fence around.

Put the two side by side

Perimeter is a length, in cm.
Area is a covering, in cm squared.

The unit tells you which. If the answer has a squared unit, it must be an area.

Writing an equation that does not match the words

What it looks like

For a rectangle of length x + 4 and width x with perimeter 36 you write x + 4 + x = 36.

Why it happens

The numbers in the question all get used, which feels like the job is done, and the situation itself never gets checked.

A worked example

Question. perimeter of a rectangle x + 4 long and x wide

A common answer. x + 4 + x = 36, which is two sides

The answer. 2(x + 4) + 2x = 36

Why. A rectangle has four sides, so each length and each width is counted twice.

Put the two side by side

Two sides: x + 4 + x.
Four sides: 2(x + 4) + 2x.

Read your equation back as a sentence. If it does not describe the picture, solving it will not help.

WAJD spots these patterns in your child's answers and names the one behind their wrong answers, instead of just marking them wrong.

More maths topics