Maths

Common mistakes in the mean

7 mistakes learners make with the mean, each one named and explained.

All common mistakes

The mean shares the total out equally, so it needs the total and the count, every time.

A zero left out of the count

What it looks like

A value of zero is skipped when counting how many items there are, so the mean comes out high.

Why it happens

Zero contributes nothing to the total, so it looks as though it contributes nothing at all.

A worked example

Question. 2, 0, 3, 1, 4, 2

A common answer. 12 / 5 = 2.4

The answer. 12 / 6 = 2

Why. The zero is still a match that was played, so it still counts as one of the six.

Put the two side by side

Zero adds nothing to the total.
Zero still adds one to the count.

Count the items, not the non-zero items. A zero is data.

The group sizes attached to the wrong means

What it looks like

The weighting is applied the wrong way round, so 6 at 70 and 4 at 80 comes out as 76.

Why it happens

Four numbers in one sentence, and which size belongs to which mean is easy to cross over.

A worked example

Question. 6 pupils averaging 70 and 4 averaging 80

A common answer. (4 x 70 + 6 x 80) / 10 = 76

The answer. 74

Why. The larger group is the one averaging 70, so the answer sits below the midpoint of 75.

Put the two side by side

76 is above the midpoint of 75.
74 is below it.

Check which side of the midpoint your answer lands on. The bigger group has to win.

The mean assumed not to move

What it looks like

A new value is added to a set and the mean is given as it was before.

Why it happens

One extra value among several feels too small to shift anything.

A worked example

Question. Five pupils averaging 150 cm, joined by one of 162 cm

A common answer. the mean is still 150 cm

The answer. the mean is 152 cm

Why. The new pupil is above the old mean, so the mean has to rise.

Put the two side by side

Adding a value equal to the mean changes nothing.
Adding one above the mean pulls it up.

Compare the new value with the old mean. That tells you the direction before any arithmetic.

The missing value found without using the total

What it looks like

A missing value is guessed from the other values rather than worked back from the total.

Why it happens

Working backwards feels like a different kind of problem from working the mean out forwards.

A worked example

Question. Mean of five numbers is 12; four of them are 8, 15, 10 and 11

A common answer. 11, from the pattern of the others

The answer. 16

Why. Five numbers with a mean of 12 must total 60, and the four given total 44.

Put the two side by side

Forwards: total, then divide.
Backwards: multiply to get the total, then subtract.

Mean times count always gives the total. That single step turns any of these round.

The total given as the mean

What it looks like

The values are added up correctly and the total is written down as the answer.

Why it happens

Adding is the visible work, and dividing is one small step that is easy to skip.

A worked example

Question. 2, 0, 3, 1, 4, 2 over six matches

A common answer. 12

The answer. 2

Why. 12 is the goals scored altogether, not the goals per match.

Put the two side by side

The total answers how many altogether.
The mean answers how many each.

A mean is always smaller than the total. If yours is not, the division is missing.

The total given as the missing value

What it looks like

You correctly find the total but then give it, or the four values' total, as the answer.

Why it happens

Reaching the total feels like arriving, because it was the hard step.

A worked example

Question. Mean of five is 12; four are 8, 15, 10 and 11

A common answer. 44

The answer. 60 - 44 = 16

Why. 44 is the four values you already had, not the one you were looking for.

Put the two side by side

60 is what all five must add to.
44 is what four of them add to.

The missing value is always a difference between those two totals.

Two averages averaged as if the groups matched

What it looks like

Two group means are added and halved, so 70 for six pupils and 80 for four gives 75.

Why it happens

Averaging two numbers is the obvious move, and the group sizes look like background detail.

A worked example

Question. 6 pupils averaging 70 and 4 averaging 80

A common answer. (70 + 80) / 2 = 75

The answer. 74

Why. More pupils sat in the group averaging 70, so the answer must be pulled towards 70.

Put the two side by side

A plain mean treats both groups as the same size.
A weighted mean counts each pupil once.

Whenever the groups differ in size, go back to totals: total score over total people.

WAJD spots these patterns in your child's answers and names the one behind their wrong answers, instead of just marking them wrong.

More maths topics