Maths

Common mistakes in pythagoras' theorem

6 mistakes learners make with pythagoras' theorem, each one named and explained.

All common mistakes

The square on the hypotenuse equals the two smaller squares added, so you square first, combine, and square root at the end.

Added when the hypotenuse was already known

What it looks like

A missing shorter side is found by adding the squares rather than subtracting them.

Why it happens

Pythagoras is met first as an addition and that is the version that sticks.

A worked example

Question. Hypotenuse 13, one leg 5

A common answer. the root of 169 + 25

The answer. the root of 169 - 25, which is 12

Why. The answer must be shorter than the hypotenuse, and adding makes it longer.

Put the two side by side

Finding the hypotenuse: add the squares.
Finding a shorter side: subtract from the square on the hypotenuse.

Identify the hypotenuse first. If you already have it, you are subtracting.

Pythagoras used in a triangle with no right angle

What it looks like

Pythagoras is used to find the third side of a triangle that has no right angle.

Why it happens

It is the best-known rule for triangles, so it is used on any triangle with two known sides.

A worked example

Question. A triangle has sides 5 and 7 with a 60 degree angle between them. Can Pythagoras find the third side?

A common answer. Yes, the root of 25 + 49

The answer. No, there is no right angle

Why. Pythagoras only holds when the angle between the two shorter sides is 90 degrees.

Put the two side by side

A right angle between the two sides: a^2 + b^2 = c^2.
Any other angle: use the cosine rule.

Find the right angle before writing a^2 + b^2.

The coordinates used in place of the distances between them

What it looks like

The distance from (1, 2) to (4, 6) is worked out as the root of 4^2 + 6^2.

Why it happens

The coordinates are the numbers on the page, so they go straight into a^2 + b^2.

A worked example

Question. Find the distance between (1, 2) and (4, 6).

A common answer. root 52

The answer. 5

Why. The horizontal change is 3 and the vertical change is 4, so the distance is root(9 + 16) = 5.

Put the two side by side

4^2 + 6^2 uses where the second point is.
3^2 + 4^2 uses how far apart the points are.

Draw the right-angled triangle between the points and find its two short sides first.

The root taken before the squaring

What it looks like

The differences are added and rooted without ever being squared, giving the root of 7.

Why it happens

The formula is remembered as having a root in it and the squares are the part that drops out.

A worked example

Question. From (1, 2) to (5, 5)

A common answer. the square root of 4 + 3

The answer. the square root of 16 + 9, which is 5

Why. The 4 and the 3 have to be squared before they are added.

Put the two side by side

Root of 7: about 2.6, shorter than either side.
Root of 25: 5, longer than both.

Square, add, then root. Three steps, in that order, every time.

The sides multiplied together

What it looks like

The hypotenuse is given as the product of the two shorter sides.

Why it happens

Squaring is a multiplication, so multiplying feels like it is in the right family.

A worked example

Question. Legs of 6 cm and 8 cm

A common answer. 6 x 8 = 48

The answer. 10

Why. 48 is nearly five times the longest side of the triangle.

Put the two side by side

6 x 8 = 48.
6^2 + 8^2 = 100, and the root of that is 10.

Square each side separately. Never multiply the two different sides together.

The square of the hypotenuse given as the hypotenuse

What it looks like

With shorter sides 6 and 8 the hypotenuse is given as 100.

Why it happens

Adding the squares is the memorable step, so the working stops there.

A worked example

Question. Find the hypotenuse when the shorter sides are 6 and 8.

A common answer. 100

The answer. 10

Why. 6^2 + 8^2 = 100 is the hypotenuse squared, so the hypotenuse is root 100 = 10.

Put the two side by side

c^2 = 100 is the square of the side.
c = 10 is the side itself.

A side longer than the other two put together cannot be right. Take the square root.

WAJD spots these patterns in your child's answers and names the one behind their wrong answers, instead of just marking them wrong.

More maths topics