Maths

Common mistakes in percentage change

6 mistakes learners make with percentage change, each one named and explained.

All common mistakes

Repeated change multiplies, it does not add, and working backwards means dividing by the multiplier rather than putting the percentage back on.

A repeated change applied only once

What it looks like

Two hours of 20 per cent growth is worked out for one hour.

Why it happens

The first application is the calculation you know how to do, and it produces a complete answer.

A worked example

Question. 500 growing by 20 per cent for 2 hours

A common answer. 600

The answer. 720

Why. 600 is the figure after one hour, and the question asked for two.

Put the two side by side

After one hour: 600.
After two: 720.

Count how many times the change happens and write that many multiplications down first.

A rise and a fall of the same percentage expected to cancel

What it looks like

A price cut by 10% and then raised by 10% is said to be back where it started.

Why it happens

The two changes have the same size, so they look as though they undo each other.

A worked example

Question. £100 is cut by 10% and the new price is raised by 10%. What is it now?

A common answer. £100

The answer. £99

Why. The 10% rise is taken on £90, which is only £9.

Put the two side by side

10% off £100 removes £10.
10% on £90 adds back only £9.

Each percentage is of the amount at that moment, not of the starting amount.

Adding the percentages instead of multiplying

What it looks like

Two rises of 20% are treated as one rise of 40%, or 10% then 5% off is treated as 15% off.

Why it happens

Adding them is quicker and it is very nearly right, which is exactly what makes it stick.

A worked example

Question. 500, increased by 20% twice

A common answer. 700, from a single 40% rise

The answer. 720

Why. The second rise is 20% of 600, not of 500, so it is worth more than the first.

Put the two side by side

One rise of 40%: 500 becomes 700.
Two rises of 20%: 500 becomes 600, then 720.

Each change acts on what is there at the time. Multiply the multipliers, never add the percentages.

Percentage change worked out against the new amount

What it looks like

A price rising from £50 to £60 is given a 16.7% increase, dividing the change by the new price.

Why it happens

Both prices are in the question, and the later one feels like the one that matters.

A worked example

Question. A price rises from £50 to £60. What is the percentage increase?

A common answer. 16.7%

The answer. 20%

Why. The change is £10, compared with where the price started: 10/50 = 20%.

Put the two side by side

10/60 compares the change with the new price.
10/50 compares the change with the original price, which is what percentage change means.

Always divide the change by the original amount.

Putting the percentage back on to work backwards

What it looks like

A phone costs £240 after 20% off, and the original is given as £288.

Why it happens

Undoing a subtraction with an addition is right for numbers, and percentages look like they should behave the same way.

A worked example

Question. £240 after 20% off

A common answer. £288, which is £240 plus 20%

The answer. £300

Why. £240 is 80% of the original, so the original is 240 divided by 0.8.

Put the two side by side

20% of £300 is £60, and £300 - £60 = £240.
20% of £240 is £48, and £240 + £48 = £288, which is not where you started.

Going backwards means dividing by the multiplier. Check by going forwards again.

Repeated percentage change added up instead of compounded

What it looks like

Two years of 20 per cent growth is treated as a single 40 per cent.

Why it happens

Adding the percentages is quicker and it is very nearly right for small changes.

A worked example

Question. 500 growing by 20 per cent for 2 hours

A common answer. 500 x 1.4 = 700

The answer. 500 x 1.2 x 1.2 = 720

Why. The second increase applies to 600, not to the original 500.

Put the two side by side

40 per cent of the original: 700.
20 per cent, then 20 per cent of the new amount: 720.

Each change applies to whatever the amount is at the time. Work them one at a time.

WAJD spots these patterns in your child's answers and names the one behind their wrong answers, instead of just marking them wrong.

More maths topics