Maths

Common mistakes in magnitude

6 mistakes learners make with magnitude, each one named and explained.

All common mistakes

The magnitude is Pythagoras on the components, and it is never negative.

A three-dimensional vector measured from two components

What it looks like

The magnitude of 2i + 3j + 6k is given as root(4 + 9).

Why it happens

Magnitude is first met in two dimensions, so two components feel like all of them.

A worked example

Question. Find the magnitude of 2i + 3j + 6k

A common answer. root 13

The answer. 7

Why. All three components count: root(4 + 9 + 36) = 7.

Put the two side by side

In two dimensions: root(x^2 + y^2).
In three dimensions: root(x^2 + y^2 + z^2).

Square every component the vector has.

A unit vector made by setting each component to 1

What it looks like

The unit vector in the direction of 3i + 4j is given as i + j.

Why it happens

Unit sounds like one in each direction, so each component is made 1.

A worked example

Question. Find the unit vector in the direction of 3i + 4j

A common answer. i + j

The answer. (3i + 4j)/5

Why. A unit vector has length 1, so divide the vector by its magnitude, 5.

Put the two side by side

i + j has length root 2, not 1, and points a different way.
(3i + 4j)/5 = 0.6i + 0.8j has length 1 and the same direction.

Divide the vector by its own magnitude.

The components added to give the magnitude

What it looks like

The magnitude of 6i - 8j is given as -2, the two components combined.

Why it happens

Two numbers and a single answer wanted, and adding is the operation that needs no decision.

A worked example

Question. 6i - 8j

A common answer. 6 + (-8) = -2

The answer. the root of 36 + 64, which is 10

Why. A magnitude is a length and can never be negative.

Put the two side by side

Adding: -2.
Pythagoras on the components: 10.

A magnitude is always positive. A negative answer means no squaring happened.

The minus sign carried into the square

What it looks like

The magnitude of 3i - 4j is worked out as root(9 - 16), so it seems impossible.

Why it happens

The minus sign is kept when the component is squared.

A worked example

Question. Find the magnitude of 3i - 4j

A common answer. It cannot be found

The answer. 5

Why. (-4)^2 = 16, so the magnitude is root(9 + 16) = 5.

Put the two side by side

-4^2 written carelessly gives -16.
(-4)^2 = 16, and a square is never negative.

Square each component with its sign inside brackets.

The sides added without squaring

What it looks like

The hypotenuse is given as the two shorter sides added together.

Why it happens

The rule is remembered as the two shorter sides make the long one, which is nearly the shape of it.

A worked example

Question. Legs of 6 cm and 8 cm

A common answer. 6 + 8 = 14

The answer. 10

Why. If the hypotenuse were the sum, the triangle would be a flat line.

Put the two side by side

6 + 8 = 14, which would be a straight line.
The square root of 36 + 64 is 10, which makes a triangle.

The hypotenuse is always shorter than the other two added together. Always.

The square root never taken

What it looks like

The squares are added correctly and the total is given as the length.

Why it happens

Reaching 100 feels like arriving, because the hard arithmetic is done.

A worked example

Question. Legs of 6 and 8

A common answer. 36 + 64 = 100

The answer. the square root of 100, which is 10

Why. 100 is the area of the square on the hypotenuse, not its length.

Put the two side by side

100 is a squared quantity.
10 is a length.

Pythagoras always ends with a root. If you did not take one, you are not finished.

WAJD spots these patterns in your child's answers and names the one behind their wrong answers, instead of just marking them wrong.

More maths topics