Maths

Common mistakes in loci and construction

4 mistakes learners make with loci and construction, each one named and explained.

All common mistakes

A construction is built with compasses and left on the page, because the arcs are the evidence that it was built and not guessed.

A protractor used where compasses were required

What it looks like

You measure the angle, halve the number and draw the line, instead of constructing the bisector with arcs.

Why it happens

Measuring gets to the same line faster, and the finished page looks much the same.

A worked example

Question. Construct the bisector of an angle. What do you use?

A common answer. a protractor, to measure and halve the angle

The answer. a pair of compasses, to draw the arcs

Why. A construction question is asking for the method, and the marks are for the arcs.

Put the two side by side

Measuring gives you the answer.
Constructing shows the answer had to be there.

The word construct means compasses. A protractor answer scores nothing.

An angle given where a bearing was asked for

What it looks like

You answer 50 rather than 050, or measure from the nearest line instead of from north.

Why it happens

A bearing is an angle, so any correctly measured angle feels like a correct answer.

A worked example

Question. A bearing is measured as fifty degrees. How is it written?

A common answer. 50 degrees

The answer. 050

Why. A bearing is always three figures, measured clockwise from north.

Put the two side by side

An angle is measured between two lines.
A bearing is measured clockwise from north, in three figures.

Check two things every time: measured from north, and written with three figures.

The construction arcs rubbed out

What it looks like

You tidy the diagram by erasing the arcs once the line is drawn.

Why it happens

The arcs look like rough working, and rough working is what you have always been told to rub out.

A worked example

Question. You have bisected a line with compasses. What should you do with the arcs?

A common answer. rub them out so the diagram is neat

The answer. leave them on the page

Why. The arcs are the working. Without them the line is just a line you might have guessed.

Put the two side by side

A neat diagram hides the method.
The arcs are the method.

Leave every mark. Marks are given for the arcs, not for tidiness.

The region a fixed distance from a line drawn as a rectangle

What it looks like

You draw the set of points 3 cm from a line segment as a plain rectangle, with square corners at the ends.

Why it happens

The two long sides are easy to see, and the ends are easy to close off with a straight edge.

A worked example

Question. What shape is the set of points exactly 3 cm from a line segment?

A common answer. a rectangle around it

The answer. two parallel lines joined by a semicircle at each end

Why. At the ends the nearest part of the segment is a single point, so the boundary curves round it.

Put the two side by side

Beside the segment the boundary is straight.
Past the ends it curves around the end point.

Ask what the nearest point is. If it is an end, you are drawing part of a circle.

WAJD spots these patterns in your child's answers and names the one behind their wrong answers, instead of just marking them wrong.

More maths topics