Maths

Common mistakes in fractions of an amount

6 mistakes learners make with fractions of an amount, each one named and explained.

All common mistakes

Divide by the bottom number to find one part, then multiply by the top number to find how many parts you want.

A bigger denominator expected to give a bigger share

What it looks like

1/8 of 40 is said to be more than 1/4 of 40, because 8 is bigger than 4.

Why it happens

Bigger numbers usually mean bigger amounts, so the bigger denominator seems to give more.

A worked example

Question. Which is more, 1/8 of 40 or 1/4 of 40?

A common answer. 1/8 of 40

The answer. 1/4 of 40

Why. 1/8 of 40 is 5 and 1/4 of 40 is 10. Sharing between more people gives each less.

Put the two side by side

1/4 of 40: shared between 4, each share is 10.
1/8 of 40: shared between 8, each share is 5.

The denominator says how many shares. More shares means smaller ones.

A different fraction of the amount found

What it looks like

A fraction of an amount is worked out for the wrong number of parts.

Why it happens

The two numbers in the fraction are both used and it is easy to use them the wrong way round.

A worked example

Question. 2/5 of 45

A common answer. 15, which is one third

The answer. 18

Why. 45 divided by 5 is 9, and two of those is 18.

Put the two side by side

One fifth of 45 is 9.
Two fifths is 18.

Divide by the bottom number first and write that down. Then multiply by the top.

Every whole treated as 100 of something

What it looks like

A quarter of an hour is given as 25 minutes, or a third of a day as 33 hours.

Why it happens

Money and percentages both have 100 in the whole, so 100 is used whatever the unit.

A worked example

Question. What is 1/4 of an hour in minutes?

A common answer. 25 minutes

The answer. 15 minutes

Why. An hour is 60 minutes, and 60 divided by 4 is 15.

Put the two side by side

1/4 of £1 = 25p: there are 100 pence in a pound.
1/4 of an hour = 15 minutes: there are 60 minutes in an hour.

Write the whole in the smaller unit first, then take the fraction.

Finding one part and stopping

What it looks like

2/5 of 45 is answered as 9, which is one fifth rather than two fifths.

Why it happens

Dividing by 5 is the hard half of the work and it was done correctly, so it feels finished.

A worked example

Question. 2/5 of 45

A common answer. 9, which is one fifth

The answer. 18

Why. One fifth is 9, and the question asks for two of them.

Put the two side by side

1/5 of 45 = 9.
2/5 of 45 = 18, which is 9 twice.

Divide by the bottom, then multiply by the top. Two steps, every time.

Multiplying by the top and forgetting the bottom

What it looks like

2/5 of 45 is answered as 90, which is 45 multiplied by 2.

Why it happens

The word of does mean multiply, and only half of the fraction made it into the calculation.

A worked example

Question. 2/5 of 45

A common answer. 90, which is more than you started with

The answer. 18

Why. Two fifths of something has to be smaller than the something, so 90 cannot be right before you check anything else.

Put the two side by side

45 x 2 = 90, larger.
45 x 2/5 = 18, smaller.

Sense check first. A fraction below 1 always makes the amount smaller.

The part treated as the whole when working backwards

What it looks like

3/4 of a number is 24, and the number is given as 18.

Why it happens

Finding a fraction of an amount is the usual question, so the fraction is applied to 24 instead of working back from it.

A worked example

Question. 3/4 of a number is 24. What is the number?

A common answer. 18

The answer. 32

Why. 24 is three quarters, so one quarter is 8 and the whole is 32.

Put the two side by side

3/4 of 24 = 18: here the 24 is the whole.
3/4 of a number = 24: here the 24 is the part, so the whole is 32.

Ask whether the number given is the whole or the part before calculating.

WAJD spots these patterns in your child's answers and names the one behind their wrong answers, instead of just marking them wrong.

More maths topics