Maths

Common mistakes in circles

6 mistakes learners make with circles, each one named and explained.

All common mistakes

Area uses the radius squared; circumference uses the radius once.

Circumference calculated where area was wanted

What it looks like

2 pi r is worked out and given as the area of the circle.

Why it happens

Both formulas start with pi and use the radius, and there are only two of them to confuse.

A worked example

Question. Radius 7 cm, pi = 3.14

A common answer. 2 x 3.14 x 7 = 43.96

The answer. 3.14 x 49 = 153.86

Why. Area needs the radius squared, which is what makes the unit cm squared.

Put the two side by side

Circumference: pi times the diameter. A length.
Area: pi times the radius squared. A covering.

Only one of the two formulas has a square in it, and it is the one that gives a squared unit.

Pi squared along with the radius

What it looks like

With r = 3 the area is worked out as (3 x pi)^2, about 88.8.

Why it happens

pi x 3 is typed in first and then squared, because the square looks as if it belongs to everything.

A worked example

Question. Find the area of a circle of radius 3 cm, to 1 decimal place.

A common answer. 88.8 cm^2

The answer. 28.3 cm^2

Why. Only the radius is squared: pi x 3^2 = 9pi = 28.3.

Put the two side by side

(pi x 3)^2 squares pi as well.
pi x 3^2 squares only the 3.

Square the radius first, then multiply by pi.

The diameter used where the radius belongs

What it looks like

The radius is doubled before being put into the area formula, in one place or both.

Why it happens

Circle questions give sometimes the radius and sometimes the diameter, so a conversion habit forms.

A worked example

Question. Radius 7 cm

A common answer. using 14 in the formula

The answer. using 7

Why. The question already gave the radius, so nothing needed converting.

Put the two side by side

Radius: centre to edge.
Diameter: all the way across, twice the radius.

Read which one you were given before touching the formula. Convert only if you must.

The radius not squared

What it looks like

Area is worked out as pi times r, with the square never applied.

Why it happens

The small raised 2 is easy to lose when copying the formula down.

A worked example

Question. Radius 7 cm, pi = 3.14

A common answer. 3.14 x 7 = 21.98

The answer. 3.14 x 7 x 7 = 153.86

Why. Without the square the answer is a length, not an area.

Put the two side by side

pi r: not a formula for anything.
pi r squared: the area.

Write the formula out in full before substituting. The square then cannot go missing.

The straight edge left out of a part circle's perimeter

What it looks like

The perimeter of a semicircle of diameter 10 cm is given as 5pi, with the straight edge left out.

Why it happens

The perimeter of a circle is its circumference, so half of it seems to be the whole answer.

A worked example

Question. Find the perimeter of a semicircle with diameter 10 cm.

A common answer. 5pi cm

The answer. 5pi + 10 cm

Why. The perimeter goes round the curved half and back along the diameter.

Put the two side by side

The curved edge is half the circumference: 5pi.
The perimeter is the curve plus the straight edge: 5pi + 10.

Trace the edge with a finger. Every edge you touch counts.

The whole circle given for a sector

What it looks like

The full circle area is worked out and the fraction for the angle is never applied.

Why it happens

Working out the circle is the substantial step, and it produces a complete-looking answer.

A worked example

Question. A 90 degree sector, radius 6, pi = 3.14

A common answer. 3.14 x 36 = 113.04

The answer. 113.04 / 4 = 28.26

Why. 90 degrees is a quarter of the full 360.

Put the two side by side

The whole circle: 113.04.
A quarter of it: 28.26.

Work out the fraction of 360 first and write it down. Then it cannot be forgotten.

WAJD spots these patterns in your child's answers and names the one behind their wrong answers, instead of just marking them wrong.

More maths topics