Maths

Common mistakes in circle theorems

4 mistakes learners make with circle theorems, each one named and explained.

All common mistakes

Every circle theorem has a condition attached, and the condition is the part that decides whether it applies.

A radius assumed to cut any chord it meets in half

What it looks like

You mark the two halves of a chord equal because a radius crosses it, at any angle.

Why it happens

The radius comes from the centre, and anything from the centre feels symmetrical.

A worked example

Question. A radius crosses a chord. Does it cut the chord in half?

A common answer. yes, because it comes from the centre

The answer. only if it meets the chord at a right angle

Why. The perpendicular from the centre bisects the chord; a radius at any other angle does not.

Put the two side by side

A radius through a chord does nothing on its own.
A radius perpendicular to a chord bisects it.

Look for the right angle mark. Without it there is no bisection.

Angles on the same chord assumed equal wherever they sit

What it looks like

You mark two angles as equal because they stand on the same chord, with one above the chord and one below it.

Why it happens

The chord is the thing you can see, and the segment it divides the circle into is not drawn in.

A worked example

Question. Two angles stand on the same chord, one in each segment. Are they equal?

A common answer. yes, same chord means same angle

The answer. no. They are equal only in the same segment, and here they add to 180 degrees

Why. Across the chord the two angles are the opposite angles of a cyclic quadrilateral.

Put the two side by side

Same segment: the angles are equal.
Opposite segments: the angles add to 180 degrees.

Shade the segment. Equal angles have to be standing in the same shaded piece.

Every triangle drawn in a circle taken to be right-angled

What it looks like

You mark a right angle in a triangle whose three vertices are on the circle, with no diameter anywhere.

Why it happens

The theorem is memorable and the picture looks the same, so the condition about the diameter drops away.

A worked example

Question. A triangle has all three vertices on a circle. Is it right-angled?

A common answer. yes, triangles in a circle are right-angled

The answer. only if one of its sides is a diameter

Why. The right angle comes from the semicircle, so without a diameter there is no semicircle.

Put the two side by side

Any three points on a circle make a triangle.
Only a diameter makes it right-angled.

Find the diameter first. No diameter, no right angle.

The angle at the centre rule used on a cyclic quadrilateral

What it looks like

A shape has three vertices on the circle and one at the centre, and you treat the angle at the centre as the one that adds to 180.

Why it happens

Both rules are about four points and a circle, and the picture is nearly the same.

A worked example

Question. A quadrilateral has three vertices on the circle and the fourth at the centre. Which rule applies?

A common answer. opposite angles add to 180 degrees

The answer. the angle at the centre is twice the angle at the circumference

Why. Opposite angles adding to 180 needs all four vertices on the circle.

Put the two side by side

All four vertices on the circle: opposite angles add to 180.
One vertex at the centre: the centre angle is double.

Count how many vertices are actually on the circle before picking the rule.

WAJD spots these patterns in your child's answers and names the one behind their wrong answers, instead of just marking them wrong.

More maths topics