Maths

Common mistakes in adding and subtracting negatives

6 mistakes learners make with adding and subtracting negatives, each one named and explained.

All common mistakes

The sign is part of the number, and every operation is a walk along the number line in one direction or the other.

Adding a negative treated as adding

What it looks like

5 + -2 is answered as 7.

Why it happens

The plus sign is read and the minus fixed to the 2 is overlooked.

A worked example

Question. Work out 5 + -2

A common answer. 7

The answer. 3

Why. Adding a negative is the same as subtracting, so 5 + -2 = 5 - 2 = 3.

Put the two side by side

5 + 2 = 7: add two.
5 + -2 = 3: add negative two, which takes two away.

Read the sign fixed to the number, not just the operation in front of it.

Movement along the number line in the wrong direction

What it looks like

A temperature rising from minus 6 by 9 degrees is given as minus 3.

Why it happens

Working with a negative starting point makes it unclear which way rising moves you.

A worked example

Question. -6 degrees rising by 9 degrees

A common answer. -3

The answer. 3

Why. Rising 6 degrees reaches zero, and the remaining 3 takes it above.

Put the two side by side

-6 plus 6 is 0.
Another 3 gives 3.

Draw the number line and step along it. Rising always moves right, whatever you start from.

Ordering negatives by the size of the digits

What it looks like

Asked to order -3, -1.5 and -0.2 you put -0.2 first, then -1.5, then -3.

Why it happens

Three is bigger than two, and it takes a while for the number line to overrule that.

A worked example

Question. -3 and -0.2

A common answer. -0.2 is smaller, because 0.2 is smaller than 3

The answer. -3 is smaller

Why. -3 is further left on the line, and further left always means smaller.

Put the two side by side

On the line: -3, then -1.5, then -0.2, then 0.5, then 2.
By digit size: -0.2, -1.5, -3, which is backwards.

For negatives, the bigger the digits the smaller the number. Draw the line if there is any doubt.

Subtracting from a negative moved towards zero

What it looks like

-4 - 3 is answered as -1, or as 1.

Why it happens

The 3 and the 4 are combined as if the 4 were positive, so taking away 3 seems to bring the answer closer to zero.

A worked example

Question. Work out -4 - 3

A common answer. -1

The answer. -7

Why. Starting at -4 and going down 3 lands on -7.

Put the two side by side

4 - 3 = 1: start at 4 and go down 3.
-4 - 3 = -7: start at -4 and go down 3.

Subtracting a positive always moves down the number line, wherever you start.

Treating minus a negative as another subtraction

What it looks like

-3 - -2 is answered as -5.

Why it happens

Two minus signs look like more taking away, so the total gets pushed further down.

A worked example

Question. -3 - -2

A common answer. -5

The answer. -1

Why. Taking away a debt of 2 leaves you better off, so you move up the line rather than down it.

Put the two side by side

-3 - 2 = -5, moving down.
-3 - -2 = -1, moving up.

Taking away something negative sends you the other way.

Working with the digits and ignoring the sign

What it looks like

-5 + 3 is answered as 8, or as 2 with the sign left off.

Why it happens

The digits are the familiar part, so the minus sign gets treated as decoration rather than as part of the number.

A worked example

Question. -5 + 3

A common answer. 8

The answer. -2

Why. You start 5 below zero and move 3 steps towards it, which leaves you 2 below.

Put the two side by side

-5 + 3 = -2, still below zero.
5 + 3 = 8.

The sign is part of the number, not a label stuck on the front of it.

WAJD spots these patterns in your child's answers and names the one behind their wrong answers, instead of just marking them wrong.

More maths topics