Geography

Common mistakes in people and places

6 mistakes learners make with people and places, each one named and explained.

All common mistakes

Settlement, development and movement follow reasons that can be measured and compared.

A development indicator read the wrong way

What it looks like

A high infant mortality rate is treated as a sign of development, or a low one as a problem.

Why it happens

Some indicators go up as things improve and others go down, and which is which has to be recalled rather than reasoned.

A worked example

Question. A country's infant mortality rate falls sharply. What does this suggest?

A common answer. Conditions are getting worse

The answer. Health care and conditions are improving

Why. Infant mortality counts deaths, so a lower figure is a better outcome. Indicators that count bad things fall as life improves.

Put the two side by side

Indicators that count harm fall when things improve.
Indicators that count income rise when things improve.

Ask what the indicator counts before deciding which direction is good.

An effect given as the cause

What it looks like

Migration is explained by the shortage it produced, or flooding by the damage it caused.

Why it happens

Cause and effect appear in the same paragraph, and once the link is known either end can look like the start.

A worked example

Question. Why do people migrate to cities?

A common answer. Because cities become crowded

The answer. Because cities offer work and services

Why. Crowding is a consequence of migration, not its reason. The pull factor comes first.

Put the two side by side

Crowding is what migration produced.
Work and services are what drew people.

Ask which one had to exist first.

Local and global scale mixed up

What it looks like

A local answer is given to a global question, or a world pattern is used to explain one valley.

Why it happens

The same words describe both scales, so the size of the answer drifts from the size of the question.

A worked example

Question. Explain why one village floods.

A common answer. Because global sea levels are rising

The answer. Because of its own relief, drainage and land use

Why. A global trend may raise the risk everywhere, but it cannot explain why this village floods and its neighbour does not.

Put the two side by side

A global cause explains a global pattern.
A local cause explains a local difference.

Match the scale of the answer to the scale of the question.

Population density read as the total population

What it looks like

A country with more people is said to be more densely populated, whatever its size.

Why it happens

Dense sounds like lots, so the total number of people is used.

A worked example

Question. Country A has 10 million people in 100 000 km^2. Country B has 5 million in 10 000 km^2. Which is more densely populated?

A common answer. A

The answer. B

Why. Density is people per square kilometre: A has 100, B has 500.

Put the two side by side

Total population: how many people.
Population density: people per square kilometre.

Divide the people by the area before comparing.

Push and pull factors swapped

What it looks like

Better jobs in the city a migrant moves to are called a push factor.

Why it happens

Push and pull are both reasons for moving, and which is which is not tied to a place.

A worked example

Question. Better jobs in the city a migrant moves to are a

A common answer. push factor

The answer. pull factor

Why. Pull factors draw people to the new place; push factors drive them from the old one.

Put the two side by side

Push: something bad where you are, such as war or no work.
Pull: something good where you go, such as jobs or safety.

Ask which place the reason belongs to.

Urbanisation taken to mean bigger buildings

What it looks like

Urbanisation is described as a city putting up taller buildings.

Why it happens

Urban means city, so any change in a city seems to count.

A worked example

Question. What is urbanisation?

A common answer. Cities building taller buildings

The answer. A rising share of the population living in towns and cities

Why. It is about the proportion of people who live in urban areas.

Put the two side by side

A taller skyline: just building.
Urbanisation: a growing percentage of people living in towns and cities.

Urbanisation is measured as a percentage of the population.

WAJD spots these patterns in your child's answers and names the one behind their wrong answers, instead of just marking them wrong.